Holiday fulfillment has always been a balancing act for e-commerce and Amazon sellers. This year, it’s more like walking a tightrope over a fire pit with your shoelaces tied together.
Tariffs and inflation have been hanging over U.S. consumers all year. Confidence in the broader economy has slipped, even among higher-income households, and younger shoppers are tightening their budgets as layoffs climb and wage growth slows. People still want to celebrate and give gifts, but they’re watching their wallets, stretching payments, and waiting for the right deal before they commit.
At the same time, Amazon has never been more expensive or more complex to work with (despite what they keep saying about making the whole system “easier”). Between rising storage costs, AWD and FBA fee changes, partner-carrier delays, and the sunset of FBA Prep, the “just send everything in and hope for the best” holiday playbook no longer works.
The stakes are simple:
- If you run out of stock on your hero SKUs, you don’t just lose sales – you risk losing the rank you’ve spent all year (and a lot of ad spend) to build.
- If you stuff too much inventory into FBA or AWD “just in case,” you hand your margin to Amazon in the form of storage, placement, and transfer fees.
A modern holiday fulfillment strategy has to do both: keep Amazon stocked and Prime-ready while protecting your margin. That means understanding how consumers will actually shop this season, and restructuring how you use FBA, AWD, 3PLs, and backup offers around that reality.
How holiday 2025 shoppers are changing your demand curve
The holiday shopper you’re selling to in 2025 looks different from the one you were planning around even a couple of years ago.
First, they’re shopping earlier. A growing share of consumers are starting their holiday lists before Thanksgiving, not after. Searches for Christmas and gifting jump in late summer and early fall, and many buyers are intentionally spreading purchases out over weeks to avoid one painful credit card bill at the end of December.
Second, they’re paying later. Buy now, pay later (BNPL) has gone mainstream. A large majority of U.S. consumers have used it in some form, and many plan to lean on it again for holiday purchases. Gen Z and younger millennials are particularly reliant on BNPL, even as they report more job insecurity and personal budget cuts. That combination can make demand look promising early, then fragile if economic headlines get worse.
Third, they’re obsessed with value. With inflation still baked into essentials like groceries, rent, and transportation, shoppers are aggressively pruning discretionary categories – i.e. holiday and peak season purchases. When they do spend, they’re watching price and promotion timing closely. Many are browsing early but waiting for sales – especially around Black Friday and other big promo moments – before they actually complete checkout.
For Amazon sellers, that means your holiday demand curve is:
- Earlier and more stretched out
- More sensitive to price and perceived value
- More vulnerable to last-minute sentiment shifts
You may see more sessions and more add-to-carts, but smaller basket sizes and harder-fought conversions. That makes every unit of available inventory and every cent of margin on landed cost, storage, and fulfillment even more important.
Why sending “everything” into FBA is a margin trap
On the surface, the simplest way to handle nervous, early shoppers is to over-prepare: bulk up on inventory, front-load your FBA shipments, and try to make stockouts impossible.
In practice, that’s where a lot of profit disappears.
Holiday 2025 Amazon costs that hit your P&L long before the customer hits “Buy” include:
- AWD and FBA storage that gets expensive fast if inventory lingers
- Placement fees for multi-node inbounding when you send inventory directly from overseas to Amazon’s network
- Partner carrier delays, where trailers sit for days or weeks before anyone even starts receiving
- Higher transportation and handling costs on last-minute or rush shipments when you realize you’re off on your forecast
- Prep and rework costs, now that FBA Prep is going away and all labeling, kitting, and compliance work has to be done upstream
Meanwhile, your buyers are not in a rush to clear your shelves. Many will:
- Window-shop early
- Wait for your discount or lightning deal
- Compare your Amazon price to your TikTok, Shopify, Walmart, or in-store price
- Use BNPL to split payments, but still bail out if the total feels too high
So you’re paying for long-term inventory risk in an environment where demand is shakier and more promotion-driven than ever.
This is exactly where Tactical’s core holiday advice comes in: you don’t protect your Amazon business by giving Amazon all your inventory. You protect it by building buffers outside Amazon.
RELATED: Free Ebook: 2025 -2026 Supply Chain Shifts and Strategies
Protecting your Amazon FBA rank with backup offers
In a season where shoppers are cautious but still searching, the worst thing that can happen to your best listings is a hard stockout.
When your FBA inventory hits zero and there’s no backup offer attached to that ASIN, Amazon has no choice but to pull your offer. Depending on timing, that can mean losing the Best Seller badge, dropping out of the top results, and burning through far more PPC later just to claw back visibility.
One of the simplest, most effective holiday fulfillment tactics we see sellers using is also one of the least glamorous:
Add a backup FBM offer to your key Amazon listings and fulfill from outside FBA.
Here’s how that works in practice:
- You keep your FBA offer as the primary, Prime-eligible option that wins most of the buy box when inventory is healthy.
- You create a secondary FBM offer on the same ASIN, fulfilled from your 3PL, a small warehouse, or a carefully managed home/garage buffer.
- You test that FBM setup before the holiday rush to verify handling times, packaging, returns, and your WMS connections so nothing breaks when order volume spikes.
- You let the FBM offer quietly sit in the background until you hit low FBA inventory or see a delay in inbound shipments.
From Amazon’s perspective, that listing never truly “dies.” Even if FBA momentarily runs out, buyers can still place orders. And from your perspective, you’ve bought yourself time: time to let an inbound shipment finish FC transfer, time to route pallets through a 3PL instead of paying last-minute AWD fees, time to adjust PPC bids or pricing without panicking.
If you’re going to invest months of effort into rank, reviews, and conversion rate, protecting that listing with a backup offer is one of the highest-ROI moves you can make in Q4.
Building a holiday fulfillment buffer outside Amazon
Once you’ve secured your listings with backup offers, the next question is: where does all of that “backup” inventory actually live?
The answer is surprisingly simple: always keep a cushion of stock outside Amazon’s network. That can be:
- A trusted 3PL that understands Amazon routing and prep
- A small warehouse or overflow space you control
- A well-run home or garage setup for sellers at smaller volumes
The point isn’t where it is, it’s that Amazon isn’t your only option.
A practical way to structure this is to think in layers:
- Around two months of supply in FBA, ideally backing into your known lead times and sell-through rates
- Another two to four months in a 3PL or buffer warehouse, prepped, labeled, and ready to move
- Additional inventory in transit, timed to feed that buffer rather than flood AWD for long-term storage
When you split inventory like this, you give yourself options:
- If demand is softer than expected because shoppers pull back, you’re not stuck paying peak storage rates on six months of inventory inside Amazon.
- If a hero SKU takes off because a promo hits or a creator post goes viral, you can top up FBA from your buffer without waiting for another full container cycle.
- If AWD or partner carriers are congested, you can route through a 3PL that delivers directly to your assigned FCs on a predictable schedule.
At Tactical, for example, our goal is roughly five days to check-in for local FBA deliveries and about eight to ten days coast-to-coast, compared to the one-to-two-week black hole many sellers experience with partner carriers. That difference matters when consumers are actively watching for a deal and ready to buy as soon as your listing flips from “out of stock” to “available again.”
Rethinking AWD, 3PL, and MCF in a value-driven holiday season
Amazon is pushing its own supply chain services harder than ever: AWD for storage, partner carriers for transfers, MCF and Buy with Prime for non-Amazon orders.
All of those tools have their place. AWD can be efficient for fast-turn, high-volume SKUs if you’re only holding inventory for a short period. MCF can simplify operations if you’re willing to accept Amazon’s packaging and costs across channels.
But in a year where consumers are laser-focused on value, and where tariff and fee changes are already squeezing your margins, treating Amazon as your only logistics provider can backfire.
A few strategic shifts to consider in your holiday fulfillment plan:
1. Use AWD as a pass-through, not a storage unit.
If you rely on AWD, aim to keep dwell times short. Treat it like a buffer that feeds FBA, not a long-term warehouse where inventory sits for months waiting on promotions. When units stall, storage and transfer costs compound quickly.
2. Let a 3PL handle multi-node routing and placement.
Instead of paying placement fees for Amazon to split your inventory, use a 3PL that can consolidate, split, and route pallets to multiple FCs on a predictable, per-pallet basis. Tactical’s SplitSmart™ model, for example, was built specifically to deliver to roughly five Amazon FCs per shipment in about 8–10 days—skipping AWD and flattening a major line item on your P&L.
3. Separate D2C and marketplace fulfillment on purpose.
If all your inventory sits in FBA and you use MCF to fulfill Shopify, Walmart, or TikTok Shop orders, you’re doing two things that hurt you in this environment:
- Paying a premium on every non-Amazon order
- Draining inventory that should be supporting Prime sales and rank
Instead, let your 3PL hold and fulfill dedicated D2C stock. Save FBA for Amazon demand, and use your external buffer to run promos, test offers, and support BNPL-heavy channels without sacrificing your Amazon position.
Don’t ignore tariffs, prep, and landed cost in your Q4 plan
With so much attention on cutoffs and delivery speeds, it’s easy to treat tariffs and prep as “background noise.” This year, they’re not.
Tariff uncertainty and the end of de minimis for many shipments mean your landed cost per unit is structurally higher than it used to be. Misclassifications, poor documentation, or the wrong incoterms can eat more margin than a 3PL ever will. A smart holiday fulfillment strategy includes:
- Clear landed-cost modeling that bakes in duties, tariffs, and fees
- Upfront prep and labeling done correctly, so you’re not paying to fix mistakes on arrival
- A plan for how you’ll respond if tariff headlines or rate changes hit mid-season
Think of it this way: if you’re fighting for a few cents of savings on storage while leaving percentage points on the table in tariffs and rework, you’re operating upside down.
Bringing it all together: a more resilient holiday fulfillment strategy
Holiday 2025 is not a year to wing it.
You’re selling into a market where shoppers are nervous but still willing to spend, as long as they feel in control of value and timing. You’re operating in an environment where Amazon’s logistics network is powerful but increasingly expensive, and where fee changes, policy updates, and service sunsets (like FBA Prep) can shift your P&L overnight.
The sellers who will keep Amazon stocked and protect their margins this season are the ones who:
- Treat logistics as a strategic lever, not a sunk cost
- Protect their Amazon rank with backup FBM offers on key ASINs
- Build real inventory buffers outside Amazon’s network
- Use AWD, FBA, 3PLs, and MCF together—deliberately, not by default
- Take tariffs, landed cost, and prep seriously, instead of treating them as afterthoughts
If your current setup feels fragile, or if you’re not sure how to structure inventory between FBA, AWD, and a 3PL in a year like this, Tactical can help.
Tactical Logistic Solutions was built by former sellers who have lived through holiday seasons where one delayed trailer or one unexpected fee change made the difference between record profits and a painful write-off. Today, we work with brands to design holiday fulfillment strategies that keep Amazon stocked, keep customers happy, and keep margins intact.
Ready to get started? Book a call with our team.